These aquaculture-
and conservation-oriented
commentaries are not abstracts written by the original authors.
They reflect the opinions of someone else -- usually Roger Doyle. Direct quotations from the papers or
abstracts are marked with inverted commas.
225. Good growth and food
conversion in Frankentilapia
Growth and nutritional
trials on transgenic Nile tilapia containing an exogenous fish growth
hormone gene. 2001. Rahman, M.A., A. Ronyai, B.Z. Engidaw, K. Jauncey,
G. Hwang, A. Smith, E. Roderick, D. Penman, L. Varadi, and N. Maclean.
Journal of Fish Biology 59 (1):62-78.
Transgenic O. niloticus
carrying one copy of a chinook salmon growth hormone coding sequence,
coupled to an eel pout promoter sequence, grew 2.5 fold faster than
non-transgenic siblings. "Food conversion efficiency was more than
20% greater in the transgenic fish. In a second shorter-term growth
performance trial, the transgenic fish grew to about four times the size
of their non-transgenic siblings. A digestibility trial suggested that
transgenic tilapia were more efficient utilizers of protein, dry matter
and energy." The long-term trials were conducted in Hungary in
biosecure tanks, an environment where winter temperatures would have
killed any escapees. m.a.rahman@soton.ac.uk
224. Risk of genetic contamination from
feral Frankenfish
Fitness components and
ecological risk of transgenic release: a model using Japanese medaka (Oryzias
latipes). 2001. Muir, W.M., and R.D. Howard. American Naturalist
158:1-16.
This study reaches the same
conclusion as May list #196: a transgene is able to spread to a wild
population even if the gene markedly reduces a component of fitness.
This is primarily a simulation study in which some of the parameter values
were obtained from a laboratory population of medaka. The fish carried a
transgene consisting of regulatory sequence from salmon fused to the
coding sequence for human growth hormone. The transgene considerably
reduced juvenile survival in the laboratory but increased the growth rate and,
as a result, the development rate and size-dependent female fecundity of the
medaka.
The authors then constructed a
population dynamic model using the experimental and some inferred
parameter values. The important factors were, "... the probabilities of
the various genotypes mating, the number of eggs produced by each female
genotype (female fecundity), the probability that the eggs will be
fertilized by the sperm of each male genotype (male fertility), the
probability that an embryo will be a specific genotype given its parental
genotypes and the probability that the fry will survive to the next time
step or that the parents will survive to the next time step". The
authors conclude that "transgenes could spread in populations despite
high juvenile viability costs if transgenes also have sufficiently high
positive effects on other fitness components. Sensitivity analyses
indicated that transgene effects on age at sexual maturity should have the
greatest impact on transgene frequency, followed by juvenile viability
....".
Other studies suggest that transgenic
fish may have an increased predation risk, e.g. from changed feeding
behaviour. A possible defect in this simulation,
acknowledged and examined in some detail by the authors, is that
predation mortality was not included in the assessment of the model.
Accounting for it would merely involve measuring viability in an
environment where predation occurs (personal communication from W.M.
Muir). bmuir@purdue.edu
223. No genotype-environment interaction
for feeding environment
Comparative performance
of juvenile sea trout families in high and low feeding environments. 2001. Glover, K.A., J.B. Taggart, Ø. Skaala, and A.J. Teale. Journal of
Fish Biology 59 (1):105-115.
Eight full-sib families of
trout reared together showed highly significant differences in growth
rate, which the authors ascribe to genetic differences between the
families. The relative performance of the families were the same in
low-level and high-level feeding regimes. The paper does not include an
estimate of the minimum difference which might have been statistically
significant. Kevin.glover@imr.no
222. The WSSV viral genome is unique
The white spot syndrome
virus DNA genome sequence. 2001. van Hulten, M.C. , J. Witteveldt, S.
Peters, N. Kloosterboer, R. Tarchini, M. Fiers, H. Sandbrink, R.K.
Lankhorst, and J.M. Vlak. Virology 286 (1):7-22.
The entire 300 kb circular
genome of the dreaded WSSV virus has been sequenced and 184 major open reading frames (a DNA
sequence containing initiator and stop codons which is capable of coding
for an as-yet-unidentified polypeptide) were found. Only 6% of these
sequences have homologues in existing databases and the function of much
of it is simply unknown! "The collective information on WSSV and the
phylogenetic analysis ... suggest that WSSV differs profoundly from all
presently known viruses and that it is a representative of a new virus
family." marielle.vanhulten@viro.dpw.wag-ur.nl
221. Salmon choose mates for healthy offspring
'Good genes as
heterozygosity': the major histocompatability complex and mate choice in
Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). 2001. Landry, C., D. Garant, P.
Duchesne, and L. Bernatchez. Proceedings of the Royal Society (Ser. B) 268
(1473):1279-1285.
The authors of this paper
examined the mating behavior of a population of wild Atlantic salmon and
found that mates were chosen, to a statistically significant degree, for
maximizing the heterozygosity of offspring at the major histocompatability
complex (MHC). This is "presumably in order to provide them [the
offspring] with
better defence against parasites and pathogens." Microsatellite
allele and MHC data were both used in the study, and the authors were able
to show that enhancing the diversity of the peptide-binding region of the
MHC appears to be the mating objective, not merely the avoidance of
inbreeding. This is interesting not only because it is the first
demonstration that MHC genes influence mate choice in salmon but also
because of recent evidence that spawning in salmon is, superficially, more
of a free-for-all than previously supposed (see below #216 and June list
#211). landrychristian@hotmail.com
220. Ranking conservation value of
traditional breeds
Genetic diversity
measures of local European beef cattle breeds for conservation purposes. 2001. Cañón, J., P. Alexandrino, I. Bessa, C. Carleos, Y. Carretero, S.
Dunner, N. Ferran, D. Garcia, J. Jordana, D. Laloë, A. Pereira, A.
Sanchez, and K. Moazami-Goudarzi. Genetics Selection Evolution 33:311-332.
Genetic variation among and
between 18 local cattle breeds from Spain, Portugal and France were
studied at 16 microsatellite loci. The paper provides a good example of
calculations on the contribution of each breed to overall genetic
diversity of the ensemble, which allowed the authors to rank the relative
conservation values of the breeds. jcanon@eucmax.sim.ucm.es
219. Transgenic on-off switch (which might
control escaped Frankenfish?)
The lac
operator-repressor system is functional in the mouse. 2001. Cronin,
C.A., W. Gluba, and H. Scrable. Genes & Development 15:1506-1517.
A transgenic system has been
developed in Dr. Heidi Scrable's laboratory at the University of Virginia
which allows specific genes in mice to be turned on and off at will by a
simple dietary change. Although this work was done on a mammal, not a
fish, it should interest people involved in aquaculture and fisheries
conservation. In fish, similar controls might be used to eliminate unwanted
reproduction and/or put a fail-safe, "safety lock" on transgenes
for fast growth. The full text is available at http://hsc.virginia.edu/medicine/basic-sci/neurosci/1506.pdf
and a popular summary at the senior author's webpage http://hsc.virginia.edu/medicine/basic-sci/neurosci/scrable/carolyn.htm
[Carolyn Cronin].
The paper is interesting and
clearly written. In essence, what the authors did was ingeniously
"mammal-ize" the essential parts of the famous E. coli repressor
system so it would work at high efficiency in mice. The repressor system
was then engineered into a mouse in such a way as to control the
production of tyrosinase, a normal mouse gene which affects coat colour.
When fed a standard laboratory diet the transgenic mice are albino,
because the transgenic repressor protein blocks the operation of the mouse
tyrosinase gene. When a lactose analogue is added to the diet the
repressor protein changes its shape and pops off the DNA so that the
tyrosinase gene can start functioning. The mice turn brown. When lactose
feeding is stopped the mice lose their colour again when they run out of
tyrosinase. The authors are confident that their modified lac
operon can be used to control many other types of vertebrate genes, even
genes which are normally lethal early in embryonic development. hs2n@virginia.edu (Scrable).
218. Perch families may stay together
Kin-structured
subpopulations in Eurasian perch (Perca fluviatilis L.). 2001. Gerlach,
G., U. Schardt, R. Eckmann, and A. Meyer. Heredity 86 (2):213-221.
Several perch species, in North
America and Europe have been found to have genetically distinct
subpopulations and ecological sub-niches within a single lake. Two
distinct populations of P. fluviatalis were found in Lake Constance.
Lower-level substructuring or inbreeding was not detected with the 5
microsatellite loci studied. However, some shoals contained full sibs and
half sibs. "Despite females spawning in close proximity to each
other, some siblings stay together. This might suggest that perch possess
kin preferences and kin recognition." gabi.gerlach@uni-konstanz.de
217. Super-fast QTL mapping
In silico mapping of
complex disease-related traits in mice. 2001. Grupe, A., S. Germer, J.
Usuka, D. Aud, J.K. Belknap, and R.F. Klein. Science 292 (5523):1915-1918.
This is a new way to do QTL
mapping that can reduce the time required from years down to milliseconds.
Homozygous lines, phenotypic data on the lines, and a marker database are
the required raw ingredients. The authors developed a computational
procedure to predict chromosomal regions which regulate the phenotypic
traits, using a database of single nucleotide polymorphisms. "A
linkage prediction program scans a murine single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)
database and, only on the basis of known inbred strain phenotypes and
genotypes, predicts the chromosomal regions that most likely contribute to
complex traits. The computational prediction method does not require
generation and analysis of experimental intercross progeny, but it
correctly predicted the chromosomal regions identified by analysis of
experimental intercross populations for multiple traits analyzed [emphasis
added]."
Predicted chromosome locations
were compared with locations which had been independently established by
conventional backcrossing and other breeding techniques. "In summary
... 19 of 26 experimentally verified QTL intervals regulating 10
phenotypic traits were correctly identified." The computational
algorithm is available for free at http://www.mouseSNP.roche.com.
Given the likelihood that very rapid DNA-chip analyses of SNP
polymorphisms will be available for aquacultural species before too long,
the ease with which homozygous clonal lines can be produced, and the long
time scale of conventional breeding experiments, this computational
technique may have a big impact on aquaculture genetics. Marker-assisted
selection may actually become practicable. gary.peltz@roche.com
216. Pacific salmon Bacchanalia
Kinship analysis of
Pacific salmon: insights into mating, homing, and timing of reproduction. 2001.
Bentzen, P., J.B. Olsen, J.E. McLean, T.R. Seamons, and T.P. Quinn. The
Journal of Heredity 9 (2):127-136.
The authors used microsatellite
data to infer full- and half-sib relationships among pre-emergent juvenile
chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the Dungeness river. The
frenetic mating of the parent fish appears to resemble that of
Atlantic salmon in Scotland (June list #211): " single-pair matings,
polyandry in which females mated with two to three males at a single redd,
polygyny in which males mated with two females at different redds, use of
two redds by a single female, and use of one redd site by two
females". pbentzen@u.washington.edu
215. Frankendiatom larval food that doesn't
need light
Trophic conversion of an
obligate photoautotrophic organism through metabolic engineering.
2001. Zaslavskaia, L.A., J.C. Lippmeier, C. Shih, D. Ehrhardt, A.R.
Grossman, and K.E. Apt. Science 292 (5524):2073-2075.
The authors transformed the
diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum by inserting several different algal and
human glucose transporter genes. (Transporter genes code protein molecules
which mediate the transfer of other molecules across biological
membranes.) Several of the genetically engineered lines grew well in the
dark when supplied with glucose in the growth medium. Carbon yields per
litre may be 10 to 50 times higher than when the algae are grown
autotrophically. The authors suggest that production efficiencies may
increase by an order of magnitude. Ordinary Phaeodactylum is widely used
in the cultivation of shrimp and mollusc larvae. kirkapt@martekbio.com
214. Genetically unique salmon in a
re-stocked river
Fine-scale population
structure in Atlantic salmon from Maine‘s Penobscot River drainage. 2001. Spidle, A.P., W.B. Schill, B.A. Lubinski, and T.L. King.
Conservation Genetics 2 (1):11-24.
This is an important
contribution to the study of genetic diversity in the Atlantic salmon
populations of the NE Atlantic. The Penobscot river in Maine has been
heavily re-stocked at various times in the past but despite this, the
populations in the lower river and in two unstocked tributary streams are
genetically differentiated from each other. The 12 microsatellite marker
loci produced a 90% success rate in assigning fish to their
subpopulations. "Current populations are clearly isolated from each
other, however [the authors are] unable to determine from the present data
whether the populations ... are recently diverged from populations stocked
into the Penobscot River over the last century, or are aboriginal in
origin.
The degree of population
structure identified in the Penobscot drainage is noteworthy in light of
its lengthy history of systematic restocking, the geographic proximity of
the subpopulations, and the extent of the differentiation." The
salmon in several New England rivers have recently been listed as
endangered. This demonstration of genetic uniqueness of remnant
populations in re-stocked rivers will probably be used both for and
against the argument that aquaculture escapees constitute a genetic risk
to evolutionarily significant salmon populations.
See also the related paper by the
same authors which covers the whole north Atlantic : King, T.L., S.T.
Kalinowski, W.B. Schill, A.P. Spidle, and B.A. Lubinski. 2001. Population
structure of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.): a range-wide perspective
from microsatellite DNA variation. Molecular Ecology 10 (4):807-821. tim_king@usgs.gov
213. A universal primer for shrimp
mitochondria
One-step PCR
amplification of complete arthropod mitochondrial genomes. 2001.
Hwang, U.W., C.J. Park, T.S. Yong, and W. Kim. Molecular Phylogenetics and
Evolution 19 (3):345-352.
"A new PCR primer set
which enables one-step amplification of complete arthropod mitochondrial
genomes was designed from two conserved 16S rDNA regions for the long PCR
technique." One of the organisms was a crustacean, Macrobrachium
nipponense. The highly conserved primer set "can serve various
research fields, such as molecular evolution, population genetics, and
molecular phylogenetics based on DNA sequences, RFLP, and gene
rearrangement of mitochondrial genomes in arthropods and other
invertebrates". wonkim@plaza.snu.ac.kr.
212. Breeding strategies for conserving
genetic diversity
Interrelations between
effective population size and other pedigree tools for the management of
conserved populations. 2001. Caballero, A., and M.A. Toro. Genetical
Research 75:331-343.
It has become widely accepted
among conservation geneticists that breeding plans for captive populations
should strive to minimize the kinship (coancestry) of living members of
the populations. In essence, this is a diversity-maximizing strategy
because it minimizes the number of genes in the population that are
identical by descent. Coancestry is usually computed from extended
pedigree records. "Founder equivalents" and "founder genome
equivalents" are two diversity measures used in this strategy: the
authors of this paper review the relationships among these measures and
introduce a new one. The authors also give some practical broodstock
management advice and make the important point that choosing optimal
breeders and then arranging the pattern of mating among them are separate
problems. In aquaculture, for example, this distinction would mean that a
rotational mating scheme for minimizing inbreeding in a broodstock, as
often recommended, is an incomplete answer to the problem of minimizing
loss of genetic diversity. armando@uvigo.es
|